MARRIAGE RECORDS OF THE SOUTHOLD PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH
OF SOUTHOLD, SUFFOLK COUNTY, LONG ISLAND, NEW YORK
VOLUME 2
GENERAL REGISTER OF PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH OF SOUTHOLD Dated 1845
REGISTER OF THE FIRST CHURCH OF SOUTHOLD, LONG ISLAND 10 September 1851 to 31 December 1891
COPIED AND ARRANGED BY DEWITT VAN BUREN Corresponding Member of the New York Genealogical and Biographical Society

1812
2 Aug.   ORIN REEVES to Miss BETSEY TUTHILL, both of Southold.

1834
18 Oct.  JONATHAN W. HUNTTING to Miss MALVINA BROWN.

1835
10 Jan.  WILLIAM HORTON to MISS LURA HORTON.
26 Feb.  WILLIAM WELLS to Miss ENTER ALBERTSON.

1842
13 Feb.  EDWARD HUNTTING to Miss HELENE. CASE, daughter of Gordon Case.

GENERAL REGISTER 1845
Marriages by Rev. George F. Wiswell, Pastor

1846
1 July   CHARLES WRIGHT to ANN WEBS CASE.
21 Sept. HORACE PRINCE, of Charleston, S. C., to ANN TERRY.
31 Dec.  FULLARD C. PAINE to MARY SAYRE.

1847
7 July   FRANKLIN TUTHILL, M.D., to EMMA H. HORTON.
15 Aug  GEORGE W. HOBART to AMANDA C. TERRY.
27 Dec. JESSE R. SMITH, of Sagg Harbor, to LEURA R. CASE, of Southold.
29 Dec. JOHN APPLEBY to DEBORAH A. JENNINGS.

1848
28 Feb. DAVID BILLARD to Mrs. SARAH HORTON.
5 Apr.   WELLS PHILIPS to CLARINDA YOUNGS.
5 June   CHARLES D. PRESTON, M.D., of Willimantic, Conn., to HANNAH GOLDSMITH He died Aug. 1849.

1849
13 May LEWIS D. HOMAN to NANCY A. KING.
4 Sept.  ABIJAH F. MOGER to MARY H. HOWELL. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. John Howell.
            ALFRED WIGGINS to MRS. HELEN BOISSEAU, daughter of Samuel Hutchinson. Wits.: Daniel Terry and Samuel Hutchinson.
24 Dec DANIEL TERRY to HANNAH M. HUTCHINSON. Wits.: Stephen Jennings and J. Wells Hutchinson.
27 Dec. EZEKIEL WIGGINS to CATHERINE M. CLEVELAND.

1850
11 Apr.   K. F. (or R.?) TERRY to ABBEY HALLOCK.
22 Sept. JAMES CLARK to NANCY B. HORTON.
20 Oct.  SYLVESTER HAWKINS to ISABELLA GOLDSMITH. Wits.: Thomas Goldsmith and wife, Lewis Goldsmith.
2 Nov.  DANIEL G. MOORE to MALVINER P. GLOVER.  Wits.: Charles Glover, William Corey.

Register of the First Church of Southold
from 10 Sept. 1851 to 31 Dec. 1891
and also
General Register 1845
No officiating Pastor named

1851
6 Dec. GILBERT M. CASE to CYNTHIA A. WORTH. Wits.: Lydia Moore Case, Moses C. Cleveland and wife Mrs. Ency Cleveland.
24 Dec. THOMAS B. WELLS to CECELIA L. FIELD(S). Wits.: Emily (J.) Field, Mr. and Mrs. M. C. Cleveland.

1852
26 Apr.   JOHN F. YOUNGS to BETSEY M. HOWELL. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. John Howell and family, Huntting Hedges and wife [not named].
13 May   ALFRED A. BENNET(T) to MARY A. VAIL. Wits.: Thomas B. Forse, Mrs. M. A. King, Mrs. Hannah M. F. Whitaker.
22 July   CHARLES COSTA to CORDELIA REILL, both of Greenport. Wits.: Martha A. Forse, Mrs. M. A. King, Mrs. Hannah M. F. Whitaker.
25 Nov.   JAMES McCuz to MARY JANE GORDON, both of Westhampton. Wits.: J. Alanson Overton, Mrs. M. A. King, Mrs. Hannah M. F. Whitaker.

1853
26 Mar.  CHARLES C. SIMONS to ARABELLA P. GARDINER. Wits.: M. A. King, Martha A. Forse, Mrs. Hannah . M. (F.) Whitaker.
17 Apr.   JEROME B. WRASS (?), of New York City, to LYDIA M. CASE. Wits.: Mrs. Prudence Case, Dency Case, Mr. and Mrs. Daniel H. (N.?) Goldsmith.
22 June   MOSES LUTHER CASE to EMMA A. SMITH. Wits.: Asaph Monroe Youngs; Mrs. M. A. King, Mrs. Hannah M. F. Whitaker.
15 Nov.   BENJAMIN B. COREY to HARRIET NEWELL (NEWMAN ?) HUTCHINSON. Wits.: Ellen C. Shipman, Mrs. M. A. King, Harriet A. Whitaker, Mrs. H. M.
               F.Whitaker.
5 Dec.   BENJAMIN P. WILLAMSON to PAREL(L) CLEVELAND. Wits.: Mrs. Jemima Cleveland, Henry C. Cleveland.
27 Dec.  JESSE B. CONCKLYN  to FFrances ELIZA (ELIABETH ?) OVERTON. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Frands Overton, Agnes Goldsmith.
27 Dec.  JONATHAN BARNES TERRY to MARTHA J. COREY (See No. 38 below.)  Wits.: Mr. and Mars B. B. Corey; Miss C. Corey, Mrs. John O. Corey,
            Miss Julia Horton.

1854
20 Feb.  JONATHAN BARNES TERRY to MARTHA J COREY (See No. 37 above.) Wits.: Benjamin B. Corey and wife, not named; John O. Corey and wife, not named.
5 July   REV. CARSON W. ADAMS, of Wilmingston, Del., to MARTHA VIRGINIA HORTON.  Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Silas Horton, Mr. and Mrs. David (H.) Horton.
2 Oct.   JOHN GEHRENG to MARGARET SHWEM.
22 Oct.  GEORGE ADAM MAIER to CATHARINE KORN. Wits.: Benjamin Adams and wife, not named.
             BENJAMIN Y. CONKLIN to LYDIA WEBB NORTON. (See No. 43 below.) Wits.: Miss H. A. Whitaker, Mrs. H. M. Whitaker.
1 Nov.   BENJAMIN Y. CONCKLIN to LYDIA WEBB HORTON. (See No. 42 above.) Wits.: Martha A. Forse, Harriet A. Whitaker.
28 Nov.  ANDREW P. LATHAM, of Orient, L. I., to SARAH A. BEEBE. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Daniel Beebe, Mr. and Mrs. Ezra T. Beebe.

1855
24 June  SIMEON N. FROST, of New York City, to EMILY A. CASE. Wits.: Lydia Moore Case; the Congregation.
14 Aug.  FREDERICK K. TERRY to ELIZABETH BOISSEAV. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Ezra Boissesu.
7 Oct.    HENRY C. HAMMOND to ANNA HAVENS, both of Greenport. Wits.: Mrs. Martha A: Force, Mrs. Thomas B. Forse.
25 Oct.   RICHARD S. DAYTON, of New York City, to HELEN B. SEELEY, of Brooklyn. Wits.: Mrs. Freeman H. Smith, Duly (?) Smith.
5 Nov.    WILLIAM K. JONES, of Plattsburg, N. Y., to MARY G. OSBORN(E). Wits.: J. Hull Osborn(e) and family, Moses Case and family.
21 Nov.   JOSEPH ALBERT TILLINGHAST to FANNY L. SIMONS. Wits.: Philip Canterman and wife, not named.
26 Dec.   HENRY BOLL to JANE M. (Mc. ?) LUCAS. Wits.: Nicholas Munsch, Martha A. Forse.

1856

15 June   ALBERT D. OVERTON to AoxES N. GOLDSMITH. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Daniel H. Goldsmith.
22 (23 ?) June WILLIAM PRINCE to MRS. WAITTY (WAITE ?) WELLS, Of Cutchogue. Wits.: Mrs. Martha A. Forse, Mrs. Hannah M. Whitaker.
26 June   STUART T. TERRY to MARY ELIZABETH HORTON. Wits.: Mrs. Thomas (Eliza ?) Horton, Henrietta Horton, Nancy W. Horton.

1857

26 Feb.  JACOB KASIG to AMELIA LEUCHNER. Wits.: John Multhraup (?) and wife, not named.
16 Mar.  JOHN W. BENNET to JULIA A. HORTON. Wits.: J. Havens Case and wife, not named, Edward Huntting and wife, not named.
5 Apr.    HENRY ARMSNECHT to FREDERICA HOELL. Wits.: Carl Kraus, Hannah M. Whitaker.
10 Aug.  JOSEPH HULL OsBORN(E), JR. to MRS. ELIZA ELLEN LABOUTILLIER, of Brooklyn. Wits.: J. Hull Osborn(e), Sr., and family, Mrs. Lucas.
             WILLIAM S. COURTNEY, of Brooklyn, to MRS. SARAH A. EDWARDS, daughter of J. Hull Goldsmith. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. J. Hull Goldsmith and family, Miss
            Helena Goldsmith, J. Albert Wells.
12 Sept. HENRY HARRISON HAVENS to MARY FRANCES CORWIN, both of Greenport. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. J. Havens Case, Mrs. H. M. Whitaker, Mrs. M. A. Forse,
            Mr. T. B. Forse.
12 Nov. CHARLES L. BROWN to MRS. CHARRY M. SQUIRES. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Alva (Alvin ?) Squires, Mr. and Mrs. J. C. Jennings, Mrs. H. M. Whitaker.
17 Nov. GEORGE W. CORWIN, of Riverhead, to FRANCES H. HOWELL. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. John Howell, Mr. and Mrs. John F. Youngs, George M. Howell.
30 Nov.  MAURICE (MARCELLUS ?) DOUGLASS LOPER, of Shelter Island, to MARY SOPHIA HORTON. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Jonathan Horton and family, Mrs. Nancy
            B. Clark; Mrs. Martha A. Forse, Mrs. H. M. Whitaker.
21 Dec. ISAAC T. HOWELL, of Cutchogue, to HENRIETTA D. PENNY. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. (B.) Lewis Penny, Mr. and Mrs. Rensselaer Howell, Mrs. Hannah
            M. Whitaker.
23 Dec.  HENRY TALMA(D)GE to MARY CATHARINE COREY. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Jonathan B. Terry, Mr. and Mrs. Benjamin B. Corey, Mrs. H. M. Whitaker.

1858

31 Jan.  MARTIN VAN BUREN GORDON, of Beaver Dam, L. I., to ENcy J. OVERTON. Wits.: Alexander Overton, Miss Sarah C. Overton, Miss Elizabeth Overton.
1 Apr.   GILBERT HENRY LESTER to CAROLINE H. HORTON. Wits.: Jonathan Horton and family.
30 May  ADAM STRAGER to GUSTIANA KORN. Wit.: George A. Maier.
4 July   CONRAD AKER to   ____ ? SHERER. Wits.: John Multhaup and wife, not named.
30 Aug.  ASA SMITH, to MRS. SARAH SMITH. Wits.: James Smith and family.
3 Oct.   AUGUSTE WOLF to MRS. ELIZABETH KORN SEITZ. Wit.: George A. Maier.
21 Nov.  JESSE G: CASE to ELIZABETH G. DAVIS. Wit.: Jeremiah Goldsmith, Congregation.
10 Sept. JOHN W. REEVES, of Baiting Hollow, L. L, to DEBORAH SAWYER. Wits.: James Sawyer, Hannah M. Whitaker.
27 Sept.  APPLETON W. RACKET (or RACKITT), of East Marion, L. I., to MARY H. HAINES (or HAYNES). Wit.: Simeon H. Haines and family.
2 Oct.   WALTER CARPENTER, of New York City, to JERUSHA P. OVERTON. Wit.: Hannah M. Whitaker.
18 Oct.  ALBERT M. KING to PHEBE KING. No witnesses named.

1860

27 Feb.  JOHN W. HALLOCK, of Seatuck, L. I., to ADALAIDE A. PARKER, of Cutchogue. Wits.: Charles Glover, Hannah M. Whitaker.
6 May   CHARLES G. OSBORN, of Brooklyn, to MARIA H. HAINES (or HAYNES). Wits.: Simeon H. Haines and family.
9 July   JABEZ A. COLTER to ALETTA M. CORWIN. Wit.: Hannah M. Whitaker.
15 Sept.HENRY H. WILLIAMS to ROSA H. OVERTON. Wits.: John C. Overton, Hannah M. Whitaker.
4 Nov.   WILLIAM H. TILLINGHAST to DEBORAH BAILEY, of Gardiner, Maine. Wits.: Price Salmon and family.
11 Nov.  HORACE P. TILLINGHAST to JANE A. REEVE. Wits.: Charles Reeve and wife, not named.
21 Nov.  GEORGE H. TUTHILL, JR., of Aquebogue, to NANCY BEEBE. Wits.: Congregation.
            D. HALSEY HALLOCK, of Northville, to MARIETTA ALETHEA TERRY. Wits.: Congregation.
12 Dec  ALBERT F. BEEBE, of Orient, L. I., to HELEN M. PRINCE. Wits.: Phoebe Prince, Congregation.
24 Dec.  JACOB GRATHWOHL to BARBARA KRAUS. Wits.: Anna Kraus, Hannah M. Whitaker.

1861

23 Feb. W. HENRY SQUIRES to CAROLINE A. PETERS. Wits.: Richard Peters and family, Alvin Squires and wife, not named.
16 May  GEORGE PHILLIPS to MRS. PARNEL CONKLIN. Wits.: Benjamin Boisseau and wife, not named, Moses C. Cleveland.
10 Aug.  CASPER MEYER to MARIETTA MCGAVIS(T)ON. No witnesses named.
14 Sept.  JACOB KARSHER to JULIA SCHMIDTZ. Wits.: Michael Karsher and wife, not named.
16 Sept.  JOHANNES HAUPT to MARIE RAUSCH. Wits.: James H. Richmond, Warren Richmond.
31 Dec.   BENJAMIN RILEY PENNY to GEORGIE ANNA SQUIRES. Wits.: Alvin Squires and family.

1862

28 Jan.   WILLIAM H. TUTHILL to BETSEY BOOTH. Wits.: William Booth and family.
20 Apr.   EGBERT EUGENE HORTON to MARGARET DEFOREST HORTON. Wits.: David L. Horton and family.
29 Apr.   HENRY ADAMS to M.   HEB ("both 3 days in America"). Wit.: Benjamin Adams.
23 Aug.   ANSEL D. GRIFFING of Westhampton to MARY MARIA CONKLIN. Wits.: David T. Conklin, Hannah M. Whitaker.
26 Aug.   HENRY K. WOOD, of Co. H., 127th. N. Y. Vol., of Cutchogue, to LYDIA W. FIELD. Wits.: Thomas B. Wells and wife, not named, Emily J. Field.
21 Oct.   BRADLEY S. WIGGINS, of Cutchogue, to JULIETTE MELVILLE TUTHILL. Wits.: Thomas V. Tuthill and wife, not named.
9 Dec.   SIMEEON A. PRESBREY, of Taunton, Mass., to ADELAIDE M. OvERToN, of Greenport. Wit.: Hannah M. Whitaker.

1863

19 Mar. STEPHEN DAVIS, of Guilford, Conn., to ABBIE M. SMITH. Wit.: Josiah Smith.
29 July CHARLES S. ASHBEY to ABBIE H. OSBORN, both of Brooklyn. Marriage in Brooklyn. Wits.: J. Hull Osborn and family, Lydia Moore Case, Pamelia A.
            Moore.
26 Oct. AUSTIN B. BOOTH to MRS. JULIA ANTOINETTE AsTEN, daughter of Capt. William Sinclair. Wit.: Hannah Overton.
24 Nov. DANIEL GILBERT CASE to HETTIE T. WELLS. Wits.: Jona. H. Case, M.D., and wife, not named.

1864

11 Jan.  REV. JAMES BYRON FINCH to ADELAIDE VIRGINIA TERRY, second daughter of Henry H. Terry. Married in Cong. Church of Orient. Wits.: Henry H. Terry and
            family.
17 Apr.  JAMES HENRY Youngs, of Orient, First Lieut., Co. H., 127th. Reg. N. Y. S. V., to MARY ELLEN OVERTON. Wits.: Francis Overton and family.
19 Apr. CORDELLO D. ELMER, A. M., of Greenport, Editor, to HANNAH ELIZABETH GOLDSMITH. Wits.: Jeremiah Goldsmith and family, Hannah M. Whitaker, Martha
            Day Horton.
26 June GOTTLEIB FRANK HOMMEL, of Co. H., 127th. N. Y. S. Vol., to ANNA KRAUS. Wits.: Carl Kraus and wife, not named, Hannah M. Whitaker.
29 Oct.  JOHN H. FLEMING, of Poughkeepsie to CAROLINE S. HORTON, of Southold.  Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. John Jones, Mr. and Mrs. Charles Norton, Mrs. Lura Horton.
15 Nov. SAMUEL G. BAILY, of California, to DEIDAMIA L. BOOTS, of Fire Place, L. I. Wits.: Capt. Erastus H. Booth, Mr. and Mrs. W. H. Tillinghast.
24 Nov. ADDISON G. CONKLIN to HANNAH W. RICHMOND. Wits.: James Richmond and family.

1865

16 Oct. SEPTIMUS G. CAMP, of Covington, Georgia, to VIRGINIA BEACH, of Southold. Wits.: Congregation.
7 Nov.  EBEN B. BAKER, of Dedham, Mass., to MARTHA J. RICHMOND, of Southold. Wit.: Elias H. Richmond.
23 Nov. SAMUEL DICKERSON to SUSAN J. TUTHILL, both of Southold. Wits.: J. Halsey Tuthill and family, H. M. Whitaker.
25 Dec. GEORGE RITTERBIISCH, of Cutchogue, to ELISA BUTLER, Of Holbrook. No witnesses named.

1866

25 Jan.   ALEXANDER N. BENNETT to HELEN C. HAND, both of Southold. Wits.: John C. Overton, William F. Whitaker.
17 May WILLIAM H. CORWIN to Lucy E. RICHMOND, both of Southold. Wits.: James Richmond and family.
22 July WILLIAM HARRIS PENNY, of Greenport, to CECELIA ISOPHENE CASE, of Southold. Wits.: Mrs. Leander Cook Case, Joel S. Conklin, M.D.
2 Aug. WILLIAM RYDER to ANN JANE BELL, both of New York City. Wits.: Charles Ryder and family.
26 Aug. HAZARD 0. YOUNGS to HATTIE L. ORMSBY, both of Greenport. Wits.: Martha A. Forse, H. M. Whitaker.
1 Sept. WILLIAM HENRY GORDON, of Riverhead, to HENRIETTA HARMONY HAINES, of Southold. Wits.: S. Halsey Haines and family.
4 Oct.   HENRY GAFFGA to ANNA CATHARINE SMITH, both of Southold. Wits.: Mrs. Anna C. Fleischman, Mary Fleischman.
20 Oct.  JOSEPH BENJAMIN CLEVELAND to ANNA JEFFRIES. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Jeffries.
7 Nov.  GEORGE W. DAYTON, of Brooklyn, to MARY M. HORTON, of Southold. Wits.: Silas Horton and family.
25 Dec. OHN Y. BILLARD, of Cutchogue, to SARAH A. CARPENTER, Of Southold. Wits.: Richard Carpenter and family.

1867

3 Jan.  ISAAC H. BILLARD, of Cutchogue, to MINERVA RETNIER, Of Southold. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Retnier.
24 Jan. WILLIAM A. TUTHILL, of Cutchogue, to SARAH B. ELDRIDGE, Of Southold. Wit: Franklin Booth.
10 Dec. WILLIAM EDMUND BRAGAW, of Woodside, L. I., to SARAH A. COURTNEY, daughter of J. Hull Goldsmith, of Southold. Wits.: J. H. Goldsmith, Mrs.
            Goldsmith, Mr. and Mrs. J. A. Wells.

1868 (1869?)

21 Jan.   WARREN TERRELL, of Port Jefferson, to LINA J. BAKER, of Southold. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Verity.
26 Jan.   ROBERT JEFFERSON to HARRIET SMITH PENNY, both of Southold. Wits.: Mr. and, Mrs. B. L. Penny, Mr. and Mrs. Isaac Penny.

1868

27 Jan.   GEORGE H: WILLIAMSON, of Cutchogue, to EMMA L. OVERTON, daughter of J. Alanson Overton, of Southold. Wits.: J. A. Overton and family, Mr. and Mrs.
            Josiah Smith.
29 Jan.   ROBERT S. WELLS, of Stony Brook, to LILLY S. OVERTON, daughter of Francis Overton, of Southold. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. F. Overton, H. Maria Whitaker.
6 June SHELDON R. DOWNS, of Northville, to REBECCA PETERS, of Southold. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Richard Peters, Mr. and Mrs. Daniel Terry.
23 Aug. JOSEPH CIDER to MARY SEITS, both of Southold. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Auguste Korn.

1869

18 Jan.  JONATHAN HAVENS CASE to LUCRETIA M. (JENNINGS) SALMON, both of Southold. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Alvah Salmon, Mr. and Mrs. Barna. H. Booth.
13 Feb.  GEORGE B. LEDYARD to ELLA TERRY, both of Southold. Wits.: J. B. Terry and daughter, not named, Mr. and Mrs. B. H. Terry.
9 Mar. JONATHAN H. BOISSEAU to MARTHA DAY HORTON, both of Southold. No witnesses named.
31 Mar. GLOVER PEASE to HARRIET FORDHAM. No witnesses named.
1 May JEFFREY SMITH, of Babylon, to SARAH EVELYN GLOVER, Of Southold. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Daniel Glover, Mr. and Mrs. Wells Hutchinson.
17 May GEORGE MILLER HOWELL to MARY HARRIET GOLDSMITH, both of Southold.
16 June ABRAM F. LAWRENCE, of Flushing, to CARRIE M. PECK, Of Southold. Wits.: Israel Peck and family, Mrs. Lawrence, Mrs. Whitaker and "others."
5 Nov. PATRICK WELLS to MARY E. THOMPSON. Wits.: M. A. Fossee: W. F. Whitaker. 1870
8 May LEWIS STELTRER to THERESE BALDIIS. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. M. Stelyer (?).
12 June ALBERT C. CORWIN to MARY E. APPLEBY, both of Arshamommoque. Wits.: Daniel Conklin and family, William F. Whitaker.

1871

4 Jan.  JOHN BAKER, of Greenport, to MARY KEIM, of Southold. Wits.: Mr. Keim and family.
19 Sept. JOSEPH G. FIELD, of Brooklyn, E. D., to JENNIE S. SKIDMORE, of Southold. Wits.: Mr. J. Skidmore and family.
3 Dec. HENRY A. EDGAR to HENRIETTA A. RICHMOND. Wits.: Family at parsonage.
6 Dec. ARTHUR S. CARTWRIGHT to ELLA E. SANDFORD. No witnesses named.
7 Dec.  JOHN OGDEN, of Bridgeton, to ELLEN HARRIS, of Fairton, N. J. Wits.: Family at parsonage.

1872

23 Oct.  JOSEPH WARREN JOHNSON, of Enfield, Conn., to JULIA E. BOWDITCH, of Shelter Island, at Shelter Island Hotel. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Daniel Hudson,
            Miss Louisa Bowditch, Mrs. H. M. Whitaker, Rev. N. H. Eggleston and some 50 others.
6 Nov. H. DWIGHT BEEBE, of Meridan, Conn., to FANNIE T. MULFORD, of Orient. Wits.: Benj. K. Mulford and family.
12 Nov. SILAS F. OVERTON to LOUISA H. FITRU (?), both of Peconic. No witnesses named.
3 Dec. ROLAND P. MARKS, of Chicago, to EMMA H. HUTCHINSON, of Southold. No witnesses named.
8 Dec. WARREN CARPENTER to ELISABETH R. JENNINGS, both of Southold.
16 Dec. HORATIO N. BOOTH to LOUISE G. SQUIRES, of Southold.
18 Dec. HORACE G. BENNETT to MARY A. NEILE (?), both of Southold. Wit.: Selden Bennett and family.

1873

3 July  JOHN HENRY BECHTEL to HENRIETTA B. SAWYER, Of Peconic. Wits.: H. M. Whitaker, Martha Whitaker.
15 Oct. RICHARD S. STURGES to MARY A. TUTHILL, both of Southold.
26 Nov. GEORGE W. CORNISH, of Jamaica, L. L, to GEORGIANA M. BOOTH, of Southold. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Rufus T. Howell, H. Maria Whitaker.
9 Dec. CHARLES D. TERRY, of Orient, to ADA L. PRINCE, of Peconic. Wits.: Congregation.
24 Dec.  MARTIN LEHR to ANN LEICHT, both of Southold. Wits.: Parsonage family.

1874

29 Mar. CHARLES G. COREY to SARAH E, APPLEBY, both of Peconic. Wits.: Parsonage family.
31 Mar. JESSE W. TUTHILL, of Mattituck, to MARIA B. APPLEBY, Of Peconic. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Jno. Appleby, Chauncey Tuthill.
2 Aug. NATHAN C. BROWN to ELLA 1. BENNETT, both of Amagansett. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Austin Goldsmith.
24 Sept.  REV. ELBERT WILMOT CUMINGS, Of Paw Paw, Mich., to MISS ANNIE MARIA SMITH, of Southold. Married at Greenport. Wits.: Mrs. Frances M. Smith,
            Mrs. A. M. Whitaker, Nathaniel Tuthill.
19 Nov. WILLIAM MADDREN, M. D., Of-Brooklyn, to MISS ELOISE TOPPINGWORTH, of Southold. Wits.: Congregation.

1875

25 Aug. ALONZO E. HAND to MISS MAGGIE E. HOLYEs, of Riverhead. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. H. M. Whitaker.
23,Sept.CHARLES OTTO KAHLER, of New York City, to LAURA AMELIA HAGMAYER, of Southold. Wits.: G. F. Hommell's wife, not named, Hagmayer family.
20 Oct.   CHARLES E. CASE to MARY J. GREEN. Wits.: the families.

1876

17 Jan. WILLIAM H. TERRY, to ISABELLA G. PEcK, both of Southold. Wits.: Israel Peck and family.
9 Feb. HERBERT N. FITHIAN to MARY TILLINGHAST, both of Southold. No witnesses named.
16 Mar. EZRA S. TILLINGHAST to ANNA LOUISA PHILLIPS, both of Southold. Wits.: Mrs. Jerusha William, Mrs. H. M. Whitaker.
16 May H. HOWARD HUNTTING to ANNA MARIA PEGS, both of Southold. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Israel Peck and family, Mr. and Mrs. J. W. Huntting and family,
            Hannah Maria Whitaker.
26 Sept. GEORGE C. TERRY to LIZZIE BUNCE GOLDSMITH, of Southold and Peconic. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. Rensselaer T. Goldsmith, Mr. and Mrs. William H.
            Terry, Mrs. H. M. Whitaker.
23 Nov. GEORGE PENNY to ELLA SQUIRES, of Peconic. Wits.: Mrs. H. M. Whitaker, Mrs. Mary Squires and family.

1877

10 Jan. SILAS F. GRLFFING, of West Hampton, to SARAH F. SMITH, of Peconic.Wits.: Mrs. H. M. Whitaker, Miss Sarah Whitaker, Miss Ellen Bertha Whitaker.
17 Feb. MILTON BzAmAN to MELVINA WILLIAMS. Wits.: H. M. Whitaker, Josie Horton.
30 June JOHN HENRY BLAKE to SARAH JANE HAINES. Wit.: Edward W. Haines.
30 Oct. EIOIETT R. SAYRE, of Southampton, to ALICE M. SMITH, Of Southold.Wits.: Joshua Smith and family, Sarah Whitaker.

1878

3 Feb. WILLIAM ALBERT PLACE to Lucy A. E. ROBERTS, of Stamford, Conn.Wits.: William Place and family.
22 May GEORGE E. ROWLAND, Of Setauket, to PHOEBE JANE BEEBE, Of Southold.Wits.: their parents and congregation.
         ISRAEL CASE JENNINGS to DAMARIS P. (YOUNGS) RODGERS. Wits.: George Smith, Willie Appleby, M. A. Forse, H. M. Whitaker.
17 Nov. CHARLES L. VAIL to ELLA R. COSTA, both of Greenport. Wits.: Martha A. Force, H. Maria Whitaker.

1879

15 Jan. WILLIAM LOWERY to MARGARET LINSLEY, both of Southold. Wits.: Moses and Agnes Linsley, Charles Ryder, H. Maria Whitaker.
18 Feb. GEORGE G. BENNETT to ANNA L. BREW. Wits.: Mrs. Rosa Williams and family.
17 Mar. WILLIAM VOLNEY HORTON, of Southold, to MRS. SARAH ANN FISHER, of Greenport.No witnesses named.
1 June FRANCIS COMER to MARY LIICY SINGLY. Wits.: Susan B. Bennett and family, at parsonage.
9 Oct.   THOMAS G. THORNE, of Brooklyn, to ADELAIDE L. HORTON, Of Southold. Wits.: Congregation in church, Mrs. Nancy L. Horton and guests.
11 Dec. GEORGE H. SMITH to DILLIE A. APPLEBY. Wits.: John Appleby and family, Joshua Smith and family.

1880

3 Mar. CHARLES J. WILLIAMS to EVELYN H. OSBORNE, both of Brooklyn. Marriage in Brooklyn. Wits.: Charles G. Osborne and family, Mrs. H. M. Whitaker.
6 May DAVID PAGE MOREHOUSE t0 LIICIE M. ROBINSON, of Oswego, N. Y. Marriage in Mattituck. Wits.: Philip W. Tuthill and wife, not named, James R.
            Robinson and wife.
8 June WILLIAM M. DICKERSON to MRS. JULIA A. (HORTON) BENNETT. Wits.: G. Wells Phillips and wife, not named.

1881

6 Jan.   WALTER S. WHITCOMB, of New York City, to JANLE A. SALMON. Wits.: Stephen 0. Salmon and family.
21 Apr. WILLIAM REDMOND, of Sag Harbor, to CATHARINE A. WOLFE, of Southold. Wits.: Lucy W. Wolfe, Sarah Whitaker.
28 May Wn.LLAm E. KING to MAMIE RYDER, both of Cutchogue. Wits.: Martha A. Force, Sarah Whitaker.
17 Aug. VICTOR G. GOLDSIuTH to SARAH J. MINES, both of Southold. Wits.: Edward W. Haines, Martha A. Force, Martha Whitaker.
12 Oct.   IRVING M. ACKER to LIICY MARGARET WOLFE, both of Southold. Wits.: H. M. Whitaker, Sarah Whitaker.
27 Oct.   CHARLES A. JACKSON, of Greenport, to ANNIE H. FITHIAN, of Southold. Wits.: William Y. Fithian and family, Thomas B. Force, Sarah and Martha Whitaker.
11 Dec. RICHARD N. PENNY, of Northville, to NETTLE A. VAIL, of Peconic. Wits.: Martha A. Force, Martha Whitaker.

1882

10 Sept. RICHARD BROWN CONKLIN, JR., of Hashamomak, to KATIE E. LAws, of Greenport. Wits.: Martha A. Force, L. Whitaker.

1883

29 Jan. OLIVER V. PENNEY to CAROLINE R. HORTON, both of Southold. Wits.: Prof. D. P. and Mrs. Caroline R. Horton and family, J. Asariah Horton, Mr. and Mrs. J.
            H. Boisseau.
11 Feb. HENRY WORTH CONKLIN, of Jamesport, to NANCY WIcsaAM HORTON, of Peconic. Wits.: Elisa David Horton and family, H. Maria Whitaker, Henry D.
            Horton and family, Elder and Mrs. Stuart Terry.
6 Oct. DAVID A. KING, of New Suffolk, to ELLA BREWATER TUTHILL, of New Suffolk. Wits.: Martha A. Force, H. M. Whitaker.
13 Dec. CHARLES H. HUBBARD, of Cutchogue, to ADA M. HAYNES, of Peoonic. Wits.: Eva A. Gordon, H. M. Whitaker.

1884

22 Feb. 204 JESSE H. TERRY to CAROLINE C. HUNTTING, both of Southold. Wits.: Ida S. Wells, Mattie A. Wells, Mrs. Helen E. Huntting and family.

1885

31 Jan. ANDREW SCHUHULTZ to PHOEBE DORA OVERTON, both of Southold. Wits.: Mrs. Sarah E. Overton, Isaac L. Gordon, Mrs. C. B. Tuttle.
16 Feb. GEORGE B. HORTON to ELL& S. TUTHILL, both of New Suffolk. Wits.: Annie S. Tuthill, George H. Prince, Horace B. Tuthill and family.
23 Mar. EGBERT VAIL STRONG, of Greenport, to MAMIE STRONG TERRY, of Peconic. Wits.: William E. (C.?) Terry, H. M. Whitaker, E. Bertha Whitaker.
15 Oct.   JONES (?) EDWARD GRIFFIN, of West Hampton, to AUGUSTA DORTER (?) TIENCKEN, of Quiogue, Southampton. Wits.: Martha A. Force, Martha Whitaker.

1886

4 Mar. HENRY EUGENE DAVIDS to NELLIE CORNELIA BRUSH, both of Peconic. Wits.: Martha A. Force, H. M. Whitaker.
28 Oct.   JOHN H. BREITSTADT to KATIE E. ADAMS, both of Southold. Wits.: Julia A. Lernner (?), John Davis.

1887

23 Jan.   CHARLES DANA TUTHILL to LILLIE RYDER, both of New Suffolk. Wits.: Martha Whitaker, Thomas B. Force.
14 Sept. EDWARD F. TABER, of Brooklyn, to BERTHA MAE CLEVELAND. of Southold. Wits.: Ency Cleveland, N. Hubbard Cleveland.

1888

23 Oct.   JULIUS H. BAUMANN to ELIZABETH FISHER. Wits.: Anna L. Baumann, Maggie L. Fisher.
19 Nov. WILLIAM H. ROGERS to NETTIE D. HUTCHINSON. Wits.: Carrie M. Hutchinson, H. N. (M. ?) Whitaker.

1889

15 Jan.   NATHANIEL B. CONKLIN, of Ashamomoque, to CHRISTINA O. COREY, of Greenport. Wits.: Martha A. Force, Martha Whitaker.
17 Jan.   MICHAEL FISHER to ETTIE C. WELLS. Wits.: Emily L. Havens, H. Maria Whitaker.
30 Jan. ARTHUR BURNSIDE GORDON to EMMA ELIZABETH BARTH. Wits.: Anna L. Tillinghast, Lizzie Gordon.
5 Apr. EDWARD D. BENNETT, of Peconic, to MARY F. HELFRICH, Of Mattituck. Wits.: Thomas B. Force, Martha Whitaker.
28 May FREDERICK C. WILLIAMS to ELSIE ELMER, both of Southold. Wits.: Mrs. H. E. Elmer and family, Mrs. Rosa H. Williams and daughters.
17 June ROBERT LUCHEY HADLEY to BELLE B. FITHIAN. Wits.: Orrin B. Young, Laura L. Booth.
16 Sept. CHARLES H. HOMMEL to MARY G. HORTON. Wits.: George E. Horton, Frederick C. Williams.
12 Dec. FRANK ALGERNON BLY to HELEN MOORE HuNTTING, both of Southold. Wits.: Clarence H. T. Bly, Minnie E. Terry.

1890

6 May FRANK BENNETT to EMMA GERARD ALBERTSON, both of Greenport. Wits.: William P. Bennett, H. M. Whitaker.
11 May HERMON F. STAAB, of New York, to SADIE E. ROGERS, Of Peconic. No witnesses named.
28 May ALFRED C. SIMoNs, of Southold, to MAY E. OSBORNE, of Brooklyn. Marriage in City of Brooklyn. Wits.: E. T. Weymouth, A. M. Mathier, Charles G. Osborne
            and family.
29 May EPHER WHITAKER TUTHILL, of Jamesport, to ARDELLA Y. LUCE, of Northville. Wits.: Martha A. Force, H. M. Whitaker, Thomas B. Force.
16 July GEORGE H. PRINCE, of Peconic, to ANNIE S. TUTHILL, of Greenport. Wits.: Mr. and Mrs. George B. Horton, Mr. and Mrs. Horace B. Tuthill, H. Maria Whitaker.
24 July AUGUSTUS H. WIGGINS to GRACE M. PHILLIPS, both of Greenport. Wits.: Thomas B. Force, H. Maria Whitaker.

1891

2 Feb. LOUIS LAWRANCE, of New York, to MAMIE DAvis, of Greenport. Wits.: Martha A. Force, H. Maria Whitaker.
20 June GARRET H. DURYEE to IMOGENE I. TUTHILL, both of Southold, Wits.: Angeline B. Duryee, Louis A. Tuthill.
31 Dec. LORIN WALDO BROWN, of Orient, to LUCY CORWIN GOLDSMITH, of Southold. Wits.: Salem Goldsmith and sisters, not named.