Return to Long Island Genealogy
Return to Long Island Genealogy
The strange story of the bark ELIZABETH 
By Van R. Field
 Related story on Long Island Genealogy - Memories Of An Heroic Woman

Margaret Fuller

     The bark ELIZABETH was wrecked in a summer storm at Point O’Woods on July 19, 1850 at four a.m.  At this time the only life-saving apparatus was located at the Fire Island Light, maintained by the Benevolent Life-Savers of N.Y. and manned by volunteers.
     The ELIZABETH, a 530 ton sailing vessel, sailed from Leghorn, Italy on May 17, 1850 carrying cargo, five passengers and a crew of 14.  In the cargo there was a large amount of rough cut marble, a large marble statue of George C. Calhoun, silks, liquers, oils, soap and other miscellaneous cargo. The ship was newly built and the down east Captain was Seth Hasty.  He had brought his wife Catherine along on the trip to Italy. 
     The passengers consisted of Count Giovanni Ossoli, his wife Margaret Fuller and their two-year-old son Angelino, a young Italian girl named Celeste Paolini, who acted as nursemaid for Nino as the young boy was called, and a Mr. Horace Sumner. 
     Margaret Fuller was a famous writer and feminist.  She was one of the few women admitted to the exclusive circle of writers that included Holmes, Thoreau and Emerson. 
     She had gone abroad to serve as a nurse with the troops of Garibaldi in the Italian campaign for Independence.  While in Italy she fell in love with the younger Count Ossoli who was himself a national hero.  It was to escape the press, who hounded them, that they were taking a sailing ship instead of one of the new steamships. 
     After a week at sea the Captain fell ill and soon died of smallpox.  The ship was at this time anchored off of Gibraltar.  The British refused to let a Doctor on board and quarantined the ship.  After a week with no one showing signs of the disease the ELIZABETH set sail for New York with the first mate, Mr. Bangs acting as Captain. Two days later the two-year-old Nino came down with the deadly disease. 
 After nine days of nursing by the parents the boy was on the way to recovery.  July 18th found the ELIZABETH approaching New York.  The Captain asked those aboard to pack their bags, as they would be docking in the morning.  The wind built up to gale force.  He, being inexperienced, underestimated their speed and by 2:30 a.m. they were being driven on to the coast of Long Island.  At 3:30 a.m. on July 19th the vessel struck the bar five miles east of the Fire Island light.  The second wave picked the ship up and slammed it broadside to the bar.  The force of the blow drove the cargo of marble through the ship’s side flooding the hold.  The waves were sweeping the deck, which separated the crew from the passenger’s area.  The crewmen brought the passengers one by one to the forecastle. 
     Through the rain in the gray dawn, the beach could be made out with figures moving about, beachcombers looking for debris from the wreck.  When it became obvious that no one was making any attempt to help from shore, it was decided that someone would have to swim the 200 yards and go for help.  The ship’s boats were smashed. A sailor took a life jacket and jumped over the side.  He was seen to make shore.  Another sailor followed with a spar.   Horace Sumner following their example jumped in with a plank and was seen to disappear.  After this tragic event, the rest decided to settle down and wait for rescue. 
     Carts arrived on the beach, but were used to load the exotic cargo washing ashore.  Finally the Francis metallic lifeboat arrived along with a line throwing mortar.  The men were unable to launch the heavy boat into the mountainous seas.  They made several attempts to fire a line aboard, but were unable to do so against the gale force winds.  For another two hours the lifesavers and the people on the wreck looked at each other. 
     Capt. Bangs had the men fasten ropes to planks.  The plan was to have a passenger on the plank and have it propelled by a swimming sailor, but the passengers balked.  Finally Mrs. Hasty and a crewman jumped in together to prove to the others that it could be done.  After a long struggle in which the plank turned over twice they were dragged half-conscious from the surf.  They had been carried by the current a long way down the beach.  It was not known if those aboard saw them leave the surf. 
     The Captain continued to argue with the passengers trying to convince them that the plank ride was their best chance for survival.  The passengers would not listen to him.  Finally, exasperated, he shouted, “Save yourselves!” and jumped over the side followed by most of the crew.  Four of the crew stayed aboard.  By three p.m. the ship was breaking up.  A large wave broke on the ship springing what was left of the mast.  It went down tearing up the deck and throwing everyone into the surf.  The bodies of Nino and the ship’s steward washed up on shore a short time later.  Two of the sailors managed to swim to shore.  The bodies of Ossoli and Margaret disappeared. All told, there were eight people drowned. 
     Margaret had written to friends expressing her fears of a sea voyage and of drowning.  She stated that if they were wrecked, she hoped that they would all go together. 
     An interview was given to the Providence, R.I. Journal on January 12, 1908, many years after the wreck by Capt. Arthur Dominy, Superintendent of fourth District (Long Island), U.S. Life-Saving Service.  Dominy, a life long resident of Fire Island was an eyewitness to the wreck, undoubtedly as a volunteer lifesaver.  Providence had been the hometown of Margaret Fuller. He told the following story. 
    Margaret’s brothers arrived in New York and consulted with Horace Greeley, who told them that he would stay in touch with Fire Island and if the bodies showed up he would see to it that they were properly cared for.
     The word had spread amongst the Fire Island fishermen that Greeley was on the lookout for the bodies.  When two bodies were found, they were not in good shape to be identified.  The fisherman who found them put them in his sailboat and went to New York.  He went to the editor telling him his story.  “Impossible,” said the journalist.  “It has been too long since the wreck to identify any bodies.”  The boatman did his best, but in vain, to convince Mr. Greeley of the truth of his message. He was told that a physician had stated positively, that the body, which lay in the little sailboat, was that of a woman.  Margaret was the only woman that had been lost at sea in the area.  The man’s gold teeth identified him as a rich gentleman, for no seaman of that day could afford gold fillings for his teeth. 
     The boatman returned to his craft wondering what to do next.  If the police discovered human remains aboard it would entail long and unpleasant explanations and perhaps a wait.  As he cast off and drifted down the river, the thought occurred to him to simply find a quiet spot on the beach and bury them in the sand.  He went ashore at Coney Island and back a little way from the beach, in the sand hills he buried them under the cover of darkness.  Dominy asked the man if he could find the spot again and was told that it was impossible for the area had few landmarks. 
     Most everything, that came ashore, was stolen by land sharks and pirates, even the clothes of the poor sailors who were wandering around half naked.  About $15,000 worth of silk was stolen as the dead were being buried.  The little boy was buried in an empty trunk.  His body was later reclaimed by relatives and taken for a proper burial. 
The ill-fated ship had come ashore opposite the house of Smith Oakes.  He along with Daniel Jones, Fredrick Rogers, William T. Hawkins, Daniel Neman, and Selah Wood were arrested for the crime of plundering the ELIZABETH and its passengers.  High bail was set and they were held over for the grand jury.
     At the wreck site the U.S. Revenue Cutter Mohawk stood by as the first effort were made to recover the statue.  After many tries, the statue was finally recovered in November.  Only one arm was broken.  It was successfully repaired. It was eventually unveiled at the capitol building in Columbia, South Carolina and later destroyed when Union troops under General Sherman burned the building on February 17, 1865.
     When the summer resort was founded at Point o' Woods nearly 50 years later, a bronze plaque affixed to a block of granite was erected to the memory of Margaret.  It lasted about 10 years before it washed into the sea. 

 _______________________Margaret Fuller, Chap XIX
Suffolk Democrat 1850: 7/26, 8/9, 8/16, 10/1 
Long Islander 1850: 7/26, 8/2, 8/11, 8/16, 10/4, 10/11, 11/8 
The Smithtown Star 1966: 4/14
Islip Town Bulletin 1977: 4/7
The Providence (R.I.) Sunday Journal 1908: 1/12
Harry B. Squire Collection at the Suffolk Cy Hist. Society

Many more L.I. shipwreck stories can be found in WRECKS & RESCUES by Van R. Field
available in some bookstores or from the author at 631-878-1591.